Skip to main content

The Budget, A Brief History of the Last Decade



I usually hate it when politicians compare the federal budget to a family's budget. Do the Jones have their own nuclear arsenal and print their own currency? No. But sometimes it's helpful to take the big complex abstractions of the federal budget and humanize them a little. Therefore I give you:

The Budget, A Brief History of the Last Decade As Experienced By:

The Jones Family

The Federal Government

About a decade ago, you voluntarily reduced your income.  You:

Took a lower-paying job to spend more time with your kids
Cut taxes (and then cut them again)


But you didn’t stop spending.  You:

Bought a new car, a big screen TV, and renovated your home.
Engaged in two wars overseas, promised to pay for seniors’ prescription drugs, and created a big new bureaucracy to protect the homeland.


Then the recession hit and your income suddenly dropped for reasons beyond your control:

Your boss cut back your hours or even laid you off.

Your tax receipts plummeted because while unemployed people pay taxes, they don’t pay nearly as much in taxes as employed people do, and unprofitable corporations pay even less.


At the same time, some of your costs increased as a direct result of the recession:

Your local government and for-profit service providers were feeling the pinch too so they raised prices and your property taxes went up, your heating bill just got hiked, your phone company raised rates, etc.

Your “automatic stabilizers” kicked in and people who never needed food stamps, unemployment benefits, or Medicaid before suddenly did, making those programs automatically a lot more expensive.


Even when you cut back or sold back some of the things you bought earlier in the decade, you still had to pay ongoing residual costs:

You sold the car but still need to pay higher insurance costs from an accident.

You ended a war but still need (rightfully so) to pay for (very much deserved) health care and other benefits for veterans returning from that war.


You acted to fix the problem:

This is where my cute analogy breaks down a little because, at the end of the day, households really aren’t like national governments. Households did take on new spending in the recession (paying for education or job training, even—according to Newsweek—getting plastic surgery) in an attempt to make themselves more appealing job applicants, but they also cut way, way back on most consumer spending.  The #1 reason that employers don’t hire in a recession isn’t taxes or regulations or secret Muslim-Kenyan-atheist presidents, it’s because there’s no demand for their products and services. Workers are laid off, they stop buying; companies don’t have buyers, they lay off workers; it’s a vicious cycle that no individual company or household can break.  
As the consumer-of-last-resort, you passed a stimulus package that saved 3.6 million jobs.  (Incidentally, you also got rock-bottom prices on things you had to buy anyway, like road and bridge maintenance. It’s a lot cheaper to hire construction companies when they’re desperate for work than when they’ve got offers galore. Even if you don’t buy the argument that government spending stimulates the economy, it’s hard to dispute that a recession when prices are low is exactly the right time to spend on necessary items.)  Too bad you needed to save 13 million jobs.

There were also hard-to-believe-it-really-happened-but-it-did factors.

Crazy Uncle Bob threatened to burn down your house unless you fronted him some cash for his mortgage payment. So you did. (You did not report him to the police, but in retrospect, should have.)
The entire financial system threatened to wipe out civilization as we know it unless you bailed it out. So you did. (You did not engage in widespread criminal investigations of the frauds that led to the crisis, but still should.)






Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What Two Religions Tell Us About the Modern Dating Crisis - TIME

This article is so interesting to me, and seems to touch on so many different aspects of our current culture, both secular and non. I have no objection to cosmetic surgery. I've had both lasik eye surgery and liposuction over the years -- the former an equal measure of laziness and vanity, the latter pure vanity. I'd hated that little spare tire since I was 6 years old and so one day I had it delightfully sucked right out of me! But the stories over the years about the enormous amount of plastic surgery -- particularly breast augmentations -- performed in Utah have been eye-catching (not the least of which because the Church frowns so heavily on other much-less-invasive violations of the body-is-a-temple principle, like tattoos and multiple ear-piercings in an earlobe). When we were still friends, the husband of my old roommate continually pushed her to get a 'boob job' because everyone else in their ward had gotten one and he wanted her to have bigger breasts....

Dear Jeff: Part One

A response in two parts.  Part One.  There is a Republican equivalent of Hillary Clinton and it’s not Donald Trump. It’s Mitt Romney.  Most of what shapes your opinion of Clinton isn’t true. Rather, it’s truthy , and the direct result of a 30-year-long smear campaign, very little of which has ever turned out to be true. It’s the way that many Democrats still think George W. Bush went AWOL during Vietnam even though the documents alleging it were almost immediately debunked and the way some liberals think Romney paid $0 in federal taxes because Harry Reid said so. Accusations get a lot of coverage, particularly in partisan media; debunking gets almost none. T his is what I do for a living, so I end up hav ing to read everything. I don’t design jet engines or treat patients or program software or fill cavities five days a week. I do this.* I like to joke that I read more National Review and American Spectator in any given week than most of my Republican ...

Policing Facebook

My husband says I’m a contrarian who disagrees just to disagree. To which I say, “No, I’m not. You’re wrong!” A friend shared this blog column on Facebook and I basically disagreed with every word. First and foremost — and viscerally — I disagree with policing what other people post on Facebook and shaming them for failing to follow someone else’s arbitrary standard. It’s an authoritarian impulse that I understand — dear Lord if I could prevent all sports-related posts, I would! I would! — but let's call it what it is and not cloak it in some kind of moral high ground. We can have our personal pet peeves without dressing them up as proof of society's decline.   And to be clear, these are arbitrary standards we're talking about. I’ve written before about the social media conundrum that if you only post positive things about your life and happy-smiling pictures, you’re criticized for image-branding. But if you post honest comments about depression or divo...